ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Cracking Analysis of a 20 Steel Equal-Diameter Seamless Tee

Overview of the Study

This paper from the China Petroleum Pipe Research Institute and Xinjiang Oilfield Company is a textbook example of failure analysis. The subject is an equal-diameter seamless tee made of 20 steel that cracked during hydrostatic testing. The crack occurred at the branch side, on the circumferential weld that was produced during the manufacturing of the tee. This is a critical finding because the tee was supposed to be seamless, and the presence of a circumferential weld indicates a manufacturing defect.

The authors used a comprehensive approach to identify the root cause: visual and microscopic examination, non-destructive testing, chemical composition analysis, and mechanical property testing. The results were clear and unambiguous: the tee had a severe lack of fusion defect in the circumferential weld, and this defect initiated the crack that propagated through the remaining wall thickness as the test pressure increased.

Key Technical Points and Process Interpretation

The Circumferential Weld is the Root Cause

The most significant finding is that the tee was not truly seamless. It had been manufactured by welding a branch to the main body, and this weld was the location of the failure. This is a serious quality issue because a seamless tee should not have any welds. The presence of the weld indicates that the manufacturer either used a welded construction or attempted to repair a defect by welding, which is not acceptable for a seamless product.

The circumferential weld had a severe lack of fusion defect. This means that the weld metal did not fuse completely with the base metal, leaving a gap or void in the weld. This defect acted as a stress concentration point, and when the test pressure was applied, the crack initiated at this point and propagated through the remaining wall thickness.

The Role of Hydrostatic Testing

The failure occurred during hydrostatic testing, which is a standard quality control procedure for pressure-containing equipment. The test pressure is typically 1.5 times the design pressure, and it is intended to verify the integrity of the pressure boundary. In this case, the test revealed the defect, but it also caused the failure. This is exactly what hydrostatic testing is designed to do, but the failure should not have occurred if the tee had been properly manufactured and inspected.

The authors note that the crack initiated at the lack of fusion defect and propagated as the pressure increased. This is a classic failure mechanism for a lack of fusion defect, which is a planar discontinuity that can act as a sharp crack. The propagation was likely fast, as the remaining wall thickness was not sufficient to withstand the test pressure.

Inspection and Quality Control

The paper emphasizes the importance of non-destructive testing (NDT) in detecting defects before they cause failures. The lack of fusion defect in this tee should have been detected by ultrasonic testing (UT) or radiographic testing (RT) during the manufacturing process. The fact that it was not detected indicates a failure in the quality control system.

The authors used a combination of NDT methods to characterize the defect. This is a good practice, as no single NDT method can detect all types of defects. UT is effective for detecting planar defects like lack of fusion, while RT is effective for detecting volumetric defects like porosity. The combination of methods provides a more complete picture of the defect.

Engineering Practice Insights and Reflections

The Danger of "Seamless" Claims

This case is a reminder that the term "seamless" is not a guarantee of quality. A tee can be labeled as seamless but still contain a weld if the manufacturer uses a welded construction or performs a repair. The buyer must verify the manufacturing process and ensure that the product meets the required standard. This is particularly important for pressure-containing equipment, where a weld defect can lead to catastrophic failure.

In my experience, the most reliable way to verify that a fitting is truly seamless is to require the manufacturer to provide documentation of the manufacturing process and to perform NDT on the product. The buyer should also consider performing independent NDT on a sample of the product to verify the quality.

The Importance of NDT in Fitting Manufacturing

NDT is essential for ensuring the quality of pipe fittings, but it is often not performed as thoroughly as it should be. Many manufacturers perform NDT on a sample basis, or they rely on the visual inspection of the welds. This is not sufficient for pressure-containing equipment, where every weld should be inspected.

The authors' use of multiple NDT methods is a good example of how to properly inspect a fitting. The lack of fusion defect was likely detectable by UT, but the manufacturer either did not perform UT or performed it incorrectly. The lesson is that NDT must be performed by qualified personnel using properly calibrated equipment.

The Role of Material Properties

The chemical composition and mechanical properties of the 20 steel were within the required specifications, so the material was not the cause of the failure. This is an important finding because it eliminates one potential cause and focuses attention on the weld defect. However, the material properties are still important because they determine the fracture toughness of the steel. If the steel had low toughness, the crack would have propagated more easily.

Lessons for Hydrostatic Testing

Hydrostatic testing is a critical quality control step, but it must be performed correctly. The test pressure must be applied gradually, and the pressure must be held for a sufficient time to allow any defects to be detected. In this case, the test pressure was increased until the failure occurred, which is not the correct procedure. The test should have been performed at the specified test pressure, and the pressure should have been held for the specified time.

Conclusions and Study Insights

This paper is an excellent example of failure analysis. The authors have identified the root cause of the failure with a high degree of confidence, and they have provided clear recommendations for preventing similar failures in the future. The key findings are: the tee was not truly seamless, the circumferential weld had a severe lack of fusion defect, and this defect caused the failure during hydrostatic testing.

For a practicing engineer, the most valuable takeaway is the importance of quality control in the manufacturing of pipe fittings. The buyer must verify that the product meets the required standard, and the manufacturer must perform adequate NDT to detect defects before they cause failures. The paper also highlights the importance of hydrostatic testing as a final quality control step, but it must be performed correctly.

The work is a reminder that even a simple fitting can fail if it is not manufactured properly. The failure of this tee could have been prevented by proper inspection and quality control. The paper should be read by anyone involved in the procurement or inspection of pipe fittings, as it provides a clear example of what can go wrong when quality is not properly controlled.