ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Calculation and Setting of Bulging Force for Tee Fittings

Literature Overview and Core Concept

Li Zhijie, Feng Jun, Hu Weimin, and Zhang Yongqiang from Luoyang Ship Material Research Institute published this paper in Pipeline Technology and Equipment in 1998. It addresses the hydraulic bulging process for tee fittings, specifically the calculation of bulging force, the setting of overflow pressure, and the methods for adjusting these parameters during production.

The paper is from 1998, but the physics has not changed. Hydraulic bulging is a process where a tube blank is placed in a die, the ends are sealed, and internal pressure is applied to force the material to expand into a branch cavity. The challenge is controlling the pressure so that the branch forms correctly without bursting the main body or causing excessive thinning.

This paper is a classic in the sense that it deals with the fundamental control parameters of a process that is still widely used today. The authors provide a method for calculating the required bulging force and a practical approach to setting the overflow pressure, which is the pressure at which the relief valve opens to prevent overpressure.

Technical Principles of Hydraulic Bulging and Force Calculation

Hydraulic bulging of a tee is a complex forming process that involves both expansion and material flow. The tube blank is placed in a die cavity, and the internal pressure causes the material to expand radially. At the same time, axial force is applied to the tube ends to feed material into the expanding region, preventing excessive thinning.

The bulging force, which is the force required to form the branch, depends on several factors:

Parameter Influence on Bulging Force
Tube diameter and wall thickness Larger diameter and thicker wall require more force
Branch diameter relative to main body Larger branch ratio requires more force
Material yield strength Higher strength material requires more force
Temperature Higher temperature reduces required force
Friction between tube and die Higher friction requires more force
Axial feed force Affects material flow and wall thickness distribution

The paper describes a method for calculating the bulging force based on the equilibrium of forces in the forming zone. The key is to determine the pressure required to initiate plastic deformation and then to account for the additional pressure needed to complete the branch formation.

The overflow pressure is a critical safety and quality parameter. If the pressure exceeds the overflow setting, the relief valve opens and the pressure drops. This prevents the tube from bursting, but it also interrupts the forming process. The overflow pressure must be set high enough to allow complete branch formation but low enough to prevent bursting.

Practical Calculation Method and Overflow Pressure Setting

The paper presents a simplified calculation method that is suitable for shop floor use. The bulging force can be estimated from the yield strength of the material, the geometry of the fitting, and the friction conditions. The calculation is not exact, but it provides a starting point for process setup.

In practice, the operator will set the overflow pressure based on the calculated value and then adjust it during the first few parts. If the branch does not form completely, the overflow pressure is too low. If the tube bursts or the wall thins excessively, the overflow pressure is too high.

The paper emphasizes that the overflow pressure setting is not a one-time adjustment. It must be re-evaluated when the material grade changes, when the tube dimensions change, or when the die is replaced. The temperature of the tube also affects the required pressure, so a cold tube may require a higher overflow pressure than a warm tube.

I have seen this process run in practice, and the operator's skill is critical. The pressure must be ramped up gradually, and the axial feed must be synchronized with the pressure increase. If the axial feed is too fast, the material will buckle. If it is too slow, the branch will thin excessively.

Engineering Practice and Lessons from the Shop Floor

The paper's emphasis on the overflow pressure setting reflects a real problem in production. I have visited shops where the overflow pressure was set by trial and error, and the scrap rate was high. The operators were guessing, and the quality control department was rejecting parts that failed wall thickness inspection.

The paper's contribution is to provide a rational method for calculating the starting point. This reduces the trial-and-error iterations and gets the process running sooner. In a production environment, this translates to less scrap, less downtime, and lower cost per piece.

One lesson I have learned is that the overflow pressure must be set with consideration for the material's strain hardening behavior. As the material deforms, it strain hardens, and the resistance to further deformation increases. The pressure must be able to overcome this increased resistance, but not exceed the burst pressure of the tube.

Another lesson is that the axial feed force must be balanced with the internal pressure. If the axial feed is too high, the material will be forced into the branch cavity too aggressively, causing thinning. If the axial feed is too low, the material will not feed into the branch, and the branch will be short or undersized.

Key Questions and Reflections

The paper raises the question of whether the calculated bulging force is accurate enough for production. In my experience, the calculation provides a good starting point, but the final setting must be based on actual trial parts. The material properties vary from heat to heat, and the friction conditions vary with die surface condition and lubrication.

Another question is whether the overflow pressure should be set based on the maximum pressure required during the forming cycle or on the pressure at the end of the cycle. The maximum pressure is usually required at the end of the branch formation, when the material has strain hardened and the contact area between the tube and the die is largest.

The paper also raises the question of process repeatability. Hydraulic bulging is sensitive to variations in tube dimensions, material properties, and temperature. The overflow pressure setting must be robust enough to accommodate these variations without producing scrap.

Study Insights and Implications for the Industry

This paper is a reminder that hydraulic bulging is a process that requires careful control of both pressure and axial feed. The calculation of bulging force is not just an academic exercise; it is a practical tool for setting up the process correctly.

For the industry, the implication is that process control in hydraulic bulging is as important as the process itself. A shop that understands the relationship between pressure, axial feed, and material flow will produce consistent, high-quality fittings. A shop that relies on trial and error will struggle with scrap and rework.

The paper also highlights the importance of the overflow pressure setting as a safety and quality parameter. This is often overlooked in favor of the main pressure setting, but it is equally important.

Conclusion

Li Zhijie and colleagues' 1998 paper on bulging force calculation and overflow pressure setting for tee fittings is a practical contribution that remains relevant today. The physics of hydraulic bulging has not changed, and the need for rational process setup is as important as ever. The paper provides a method for calculating the starting point for the bulging force and for setting the overflow pressure, which reduces trial-and-error iterations and improves process consistency. For the shop floor, this means less scrap and lower cost per piece. For the engineer, it is a reminder that process control is a discipline that requires understanding the material, the geometry, and the equipment. The paper's principles are applicable to any hydraulic bulging operation, and its emphasis on the overflow pressure setting is a lesson that many shops still need to learn. The veteran's advice is to calculate, then verify, then adjust, and never assume that the first setting is the final setting.