Study on the Wear Characteristics of Pipe Elbows
Literature Overview
Gao Wanfu, Zheng Yanjun, Cui Lishan from the Petroleum University, Li Ximing and Chen Yanan from Qinghai Petroleum Administration Survey and Design Institute, and Yu Longwen from Liaoning Petrochemical University published this study in 2003. It examines the wear characteristics of pipe elbows in gas-solid two-phase flow, using a negative pressure experimental system with air velocities from 5 to 30 m/s and different diameters of corundum and zirconia micro-powders as the solid particles.
The study covers four materials: 10# steel, 20# steel, 16Mn and 18-8 stainless steel. This is a classic parametric study that examines the effect of particle diameter, concentration, material type, elbow curvature radius to diameter ratio, and pipe diameter on wear rate.
Core Viewpoints
The most important finding is that the material properties have the greatest influence on wear resistance. The wear resistance ranking is 16Mn, 20# steel, 10# steel and 18-8 stainless steel. This is counterintuitive to those who assume stainless steel is always better — in erosive wear, the hardness and work hardening capacity of the material are more important than corrosion resistance.
The wear rate and air velocity have an exponential relationship, with the exponent between 1.2 and 2. This means that doubling the velocity can increase the wear rate by a factor of 2.3 to 4.0. The exponent depends on the particle size, material and hardness.
For a fixed curvature radius to diameter ratio, larger diameter elbows have lower wear rates. This is because the surface area to volume ratio is smaller for larger diameter pipes, so the same volume of particles impinges on a smaller relative area.
Interpretation of Technical Points
The key parameters and their effects are summarised below.
| Parameter | Range Studied | Effect on Wear Rate |
|---|---|---|
| Material | 10# steel, 20# steel, 16Mn, 18-8 stainless steel | 16Mn best; 18-8 stainless steel worst |
| Air velocity | 5 – 30 m/s | Exponential relationship; exponent 1.2 – 2 |
| Particle diameter | Varied | Affects wear rate and velocity exponent |
| Particle material | Corundum, zirconia | Harder particles cause more wear |
| Curvature radius / pipe diameter | Fixed ratio | Larger diameter elbows have lower wear rate |
| Particle concentration | Varied | Higher concentration increases wear rate |
The material ranking is particularly interesting. 16Mn has the best wear resistance because it has a higher hardness than 10# and 20# steel, and it work hardens under impact. 18-8 stainless steel has the worst wear resistance because it has a relatively low hardness and does not work harden as effectively as the carbon steels.
The exponential relationship between wear rate and velocity is well established in the erosion literature. The exponent of 1.2 to 2 is consistent with the theoretical models, which predict an exponent of 2 for pure erosion and a lower exponent for erosion-corrosion.
Integration with Engineering Practice
The material selection for elbows in gas-solid two-phase flow should be based on wear resistance, not just corrosion resistance. In a pneumatic conveying system, 16Mn is a better choice than 18-8 stainless steel if corrosion is not a concern.
| Application | Recommended Material | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| Pneumatic conveying of abrasive particles | 16Mn | Best wear resistance; work hardens |
| Pneumatic conveying with corrosive media | 18-8 stainless steel | Corrosion resistance; accept lower wear resistance |
| High temperature service | 20# steel or alloy steel | Maintains strength at temperature |
| Severe erosion service | Hardfacing or ceramic lining | Extend life beyond base material |
The elbow curvature radius to diameter ratio is also important. A larger radius reduces the impingement angle and the localised erosion. The study found that for a fixed ratio, larger diameter elbows have lower wear rates, which is a useful design consideration.
The particle concentration effect is linear, which means that the wear rate is directly proportional to the amount of particles flowing through the elbow. This is useful for predicting wear rates when the particle concentration is known.
Key Questions and Reflections
The study does not address the effect of the elbow angle on wear. Most elbows in conveying systems are 90 degrees, but 45 degree and 60 degree elbows are also used. The impingement angle has a significant effect on the wear rate, and this should be studied.
The effect of the particle shape is not discussed. Angular particles cause more wear than spherical particles at the same diameter. The study uses corundum and zirconia micro-powders, which are likely to be angular, but the shape is not quantified.
The study does not address the effect of the pipe wall thickness on wear life. A thicker wall provides more material to wear, but the wear rate is the same. The design should balance the wall thickness against the cost and weight.
Study Insights and Implications
The material ranking is the most valuable finding for practical design. 16Mn is the best choice for erosive service, and it is widely available at a reasonable cost. The use of 18-8 stainless steel in erosive service should be avoided unless corrosion resistance is the primary requirement.
The exponential relationship between wear rate and velocity means that reducing the velocity is the most effective way to reduce wear. A 20% reduction in velocity can reduce the wear rate by up to 36%, depending on the exponent.
Reference Value and Outlook
This paper provides a solid experimental basis for elbow wear prediction in gas-solid two-phase flow. The findings on material ranking, velocity exponent and diameter effect are directly applicable to design.
The outlook is to extend the study to include the effect of elbow angle, particle shape and temperature. A more comprehensive wear model could be developed that accounts for all these factors, and the model could be validated against field data from operating plants.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd