Erosion Study of Movable Elbows in Liquid-Solid Two-Phase Flow
Literature Overview
Li Fangmiao, Li Meiqiu from Yangtze University, Song Yang from CNPC Western Drilling Engineering, Feng Ling from Sinopec Siji Petroleum Machinery, and Feng Zhicheng from Yangtze University published this study in Petroleum Machinery in 2019. The subject is a φ76.2 mm (3 inch) type 10 long-radius movable elbow, which is used in hydraulic fracturing operations. The study uses Fluent software to simulate the erosion behaviour under different installation angles, fluid inlet velocities, solid particle mass flow rates and solid particle diameters.
This is a numerical study that complements the experimental work on gas-solid two-phase flow. The movable elbow is a critical component in fracturing equipment, and its erosion life directly affects the operational reliability of the fracturing operation.
Core Viewpoints
The erosion rate of the movable elbow first increases and then decreases as the installation angle increases, reaching a maximum at an installation angle of 3π/8 (67.5 degrees). This is an interesting finding because it suggests that the installation angle has an optimum value for minimising erosion, and that the worst angle is not the most obvious one.
The erosion rate increases with fluid inlet velocity, and the rate of increase also increases. This is consistent with the exponential relationship found in the gas-solid two-phase flow study, and it confirms that velocity is the dominant factor in erosion.
The erosion rate is linearly proportional to the solid particle mass flow rate. This is a simple and useful relationship that allows erosion prediction when the mass flow rate is known.
The effect of particle diameter is more complex. The erosion rate first decreases and then increases as the particle diameter increases, reaching a minimum at 150 μm. For particle diameters greater than 500 μm, the erosion rate growth becomes gradual.
Interpretation of Technical Points
The key parameters and their effects are summarised below.
| Parameter | Range Studied | Effect on Erosion Rate |
|---|---|---|
| Installation angle | 0 to π/2 | Maximum at 3π/8 (67.5 degrees) |
| Fluid inlet velocity | Varied | Increases with velocity; rate of increase also increases |
| Solid particle mass flow rate | Varied | Linear positive correlation |
| Solid particle diameter | Varied | Minimum at 150 μm; gradual growth beyond 500 μm |
The installation angle effect is the most interesting finding. The maximum erosion at 67.5 degrees is counterintuitive because one might expect the maximum at 90 degrees, where the flow direction change is the most abrupt. The explanation is likely related to the flow pattern and the particle trajectory. At 67.5 degrees, the particles impinge on the elbow surface at an angle that maximises the erosion rate, which is typically around 20 to 30 degrees for ductile materials.
The particle diameter effect is also interesting. The minimum erosion at 150 μm suggests that smaller particles follow the fluid streamlines and do not impinge on the elbow surface, while larger particles have enough momentum to hit the surface. The gradual growth beyond 500 μm suggests that the erosion rate becomes less sensitive to particle size once the particles are large enough to fully impinge.
Integration with Engineering Practice
The movable elbow in a fracturing operation is a critical component that must withstand high pressure, high flow rate and abrasive proppant. The study provides useful design guidance for optimising the installation angle and predicting the erosion life.
| Installation Angle | Relative Erosion Rate | Recommendation |
|---|---|---|
| 0 degrees (straight) | Low | Preferred if layout allows |
| 3π/8 (67.5 degrees) | Maximum | Avoid; worst case |
| π/2 (90 degrees) | Moderate | Acceptable but not optimal |
| π/4 (45 degrees) | Moderate | Good compromise |
The velocity effect is the most important for operational control. Reducing the flow rate is the most effective way to reduce erosion, but this may not be possible if the fracturing operation requires a specific flow rate. In this case, the material selection and the elbow geometry must be optimised.
The particle diameter effect is relevant to the proppant selection. If the proppant diameter can be chosen, a diameter around 150 μm would minimise erosion. However, the proppant diameter is typically determined by the reservoir properties, so this may not be a controllable parameter.
Key Questions and Reflections
The study uses a simplified particle tracking model in Fluent. The accuracy of the erosion prediction depends on the particle tracking model, the turbulence model and the erosion model. The study does not validate the numerical results against experimental data, which is a limitation.
The effect of the elbow curvature radius is not studied. The type 10 long-radius elbow has a specific curvature radius, and a different radius would change the flow pattern and the erosion behaviour.
The study does not consider the effect of the fluid properties, such as viscosity and density. The fracturing fluid is typically a polymer solution with non-Newtonian behaviour, which would affect the particle trajectories and the erosion rate.
Study Insights and Implications
The installation angle is a controllable parameter in the design of the fracturing equipment. The finding that the maximum erosion occurs at 67.5 degrees is important because it suggests that the elbow should be installed at an angle that avoids this value.
The velocity effect confirms that the erosion rate increases non-linearly with velocity. This means that a small reduction in flow rate can have a significant effect on the erosion life. In fracturing operations, the flow rate is often limited by the pump capacity, but the erosion life can be extended by optimising the elbow geometry and material.
Reference Value and Outlook
This paper provides useful design guidance for movable elbows in fracturing operations. The findings on installation angle, velocity, mass flow rate and particle diameter are directly applicable to the design and operation of fracturing equipment.
The outlook is to validate the numerical results against experimental data, and to extend the study to include the effect of the elbow curvature radius and the fluid properties. A more comprehensive erosion model could be developed that accounts for all these factors, and the model could be used to optimise the elbow design for maximum erosion life.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd