ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Burst Failure Analysis of Pipeline Elbows: A Practical Review

Literature Overview and Case Background

This paper investigates the burst failure of elbows in a crude mixed amine process pipeline. The investigation employed macro inspection of the burst opening, thickness measurement to assess wall thinning, and chemical composition analysis to evaluate any material degradation. The findings indicated that the failure was caused by long-term corrosion of the pipe wall by the process medium, combined with erosion from the flowing medium, resulting in progressive wall thinning that eventually led to burst failure.

This is a classic case of a corrosion-erosion failure in a process pipeline, where the combined effects of chemical attack and mechanical wear from the flowing medium reduce the wall thickness below the critical value required to contain the process pressure.

Technical Interpretation and Failure Mechanism Analysis

Corrosion and Erosion Mechanisms

The process medium in this case was crude mixed amine, which is a corrosive chemical used in various industrial processes. The medium caused long-term corrosion of the pipe wall, reducing its thickness over time. In addition, the flow of the medium caused erosion, particularly at the elbow where the flow direction changes. The combination of corrosion and erosion is often more severe than either mechanism alone, as corrosion weakens the surface layer and erosion removes it, exposing fresh material to further corrosion.

Elbows are particularly susceptible to erosion because the change in flow direction causes the fluid to impinge on the outer wall of the bend. The impingement angle and velocity determine the erosion rate. In a 90° elbow, the maximum erosion typically occurs at the extrados (outer curve) at approximately 45° from the inlet. This is where the flow is most directly impinging on the wall.

Wall Thinning and Burst Failure

The progressive wall thinning eventually reduced the elbow wall thickness below the critical value required to withstand the internal pressure. The burst failure occurred when the hoop stress in the thinned wall exceeded the ultimate tensile strength of the material. The burst opening would have occurred at the location of maximum wall thinning, which is typically at the extrados of the elbow.

The burst failure is a catastrophic event that can result in the release of the process medium, posing a significant safety and environmental risk. In this case, the failure occurred in a chemical process pipeline, which could have resulted in the release of hazardous chemicals.

Chemical Composition Analysis

The chemical composition analysis was performed to evaluate any material degradation. The results likely showed that the material composition was within the specified range, indicating that the failure was not due to material defects but rather to the service conditions. The corrosion and erosion were caused by the process medium and the flow conditions, not by any material deficiency.

Engineering Practice Implications and Lessons Learned

Design Considerations for Corrosive Service

For pipelines carrying corrosive media, the design must account for the expected corrosion rate and provide an appropriate corrosion allowance. The corrosion allowance is the additional wall thickness added to the design thickness to accommodate expected corrosion over the design life. In this case, the corrosion allowance may have been insufficient, or the actual corrosion rate may have exceeded the design value.

The design should also consider the erosion potential of the medium, particularly at elbows and other fittings where the flow direction changes. The erosion rate depends on the fluid velocity, the particle content, and the impingement angle. For high-velocity or particle-laden flows, the erosion rate can be significant, and additional wall thickness or erosion-resistant materials may be required.

Material Selection and Process Control

The material selection for the pipeline should be based on the corrosivity of the medium and the operating conditions. For crude mixed amine service, the material should have adequate corrosion resistance to the specific chemical composition and concentration. In some cases, a corrosion-resistant alloy may be required, or the process conditions may need to be controlled to minimize corrosion.

The process conditions, including temperature, pressure, and flow velocity, also affect the corrosion and erosion rates. Higher temperatures generally increase corrosion rates, while higher velocities increase erosion rates. The process design should optimize these parameters to minimize degradation while maintaining the required process performance.

Inspection and Maintenance

For pipelines in corrosive service, regular inspection is essential to monitor wall thickness and detect any degradation before it reaches a critical level. Ultrasonic thickness measurement is the primary method for this purpose, and the inspection interval should be based on the expected corrosion rate and the remaining corrosion allowance.

The inspection program should include a risk-based approach, with more frequent inspection at locations with higher corrosion or erosion potential, such as elbows, tees, and reducers. The inspection results should be used to update the corrosion rate estimates and adjust the inspection interval accordingly.

Standards and Specification Requirements

The relevant standards for process piping include ASME B31.3 for process piping and API 570 for piping inspection. These standards specify the design requirements, including the corrosion allowance, and the inspection requirements for in-service piping. The design should comply with these standards, and the inspection program should be based on the requirements of API 570 or equivalent.

Study Insights and Practical Recommendations

This failure analysis provides several practical insights for engineers involved in process piping design and maintenance:

  1. Corrosion and erosion are the primary causes of wall thinning in process pipelines, particularly at elbows and other fittings where the flow direction changes.
  2. The design must include an adequate corrosion allowance based on the expected corrosion rate and the design life. The corrosion allowance should be verified through regular inspection.
  3. Inspection programs should be risk-based, with more frequent inspection at locations with higher corrosion or erosion potential.
  4. The process conditions, including temperature, pressure, and flow velocity, should be optimized to minimize corrosion and erosion while maintaining the required process performance.

Reference Value and Outlook

This paper is a valuable reference for engineers involved in process piping design, maintenance, and failure analysis. It demonstrates a systematic approach to investigating a burst failure and identifying the root cause. The case highlights the importance of considering corrosion and erosion in the design of process pipelines and the need for regular inspection to monitor wall thickness and detect degradation before it reaches a critical level. For the industry, this case reinforces the need for a comprehensive integrity management program that includes design, inspection, and maintenance considerations.