ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Comparative Analysis of Axial Compression Performance Between Composite Rectangular and Ordinary Rectangular Concrete-Filled Steel Tube Columns

Literature Overview and Background

This paper by Liu Li, He Mingsheng, and Tang Jianping from Shihezi University and the China Water Resources and Hydropower Engineering Corporation, published in the Journal of Shihezi University (Natural Science Edition) (2016, Vol. 34, No. 4), investigates the axial compression behavior of composite rectangular concrete-filled steel tube (CFST) columns compared with ordinary rectangular CFST columns. The research is supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (Project No. 51368052).

The study focuses on columns with a relatively large aspect ratio (1.7 times), which is a challenging geometry for rectangular CFST columns. The authors conducted axial compression tests on both types of columns and compared their failure characteristics, stress states, bearing capacity, and ductility. The key finding is that the composite rectangular column—which incorporates a core circular steel tube—has a 12.5% higher bearing capacity and 4.9% greater ductility than the ordinary rectangular column.

From my perspective as a steel pipe veteran, this paper is particularly interesting because it demonstrates how the shape and configuration of the steel tube can significantly influence the performance of a composite structure. The use of a core circular tube within a rectangular outer tube is an innovative approach that leverages the superior confinement provided by a circular shape to improve the performance of the rectangular column.

Core Technical Points and Analysis

The Concept of Composite Rectangular CFST Columns

A conventional rectangular CFST column consists of a rectangular steel tube filled with concrete. The steel tube provides confinement to the concrete core, which improves the concrete's compressive strength and ductility. However, the confinement effectiveness of a rectangular tube is lower than that of a circular tube, because the flat sides of the rectangle are less effective at restraining the lateral expansion of the concrete.

The composite rectangular CFST column addresses this by placing a circular steel tube inside the rectangular tube. The core circular tube provides additional confinement to the central concrete, while the outer rectangular tube provides the overall shape and additional confinement. The concrete between the two tubes is confined by both the outer rectangular tube and the inner circular tube.

Failure Characteristics and Mechanisms

The paper reports distinct failure modes for the two types of columns:

Failure Mode Ordinary Rectangular CFST Composite Rectangular CFST
Initial failure Corner failure of the rectangular section Bulging of the short side of the rectangular section near the ends
Subsequent failure Bulging of the long side of the rectangular section Progressive bulging and local buckling of the outer tube
Overall behavior Less ductile, more brittle failure More ductile, gradual failure

The difference in failure modes is significant. The ordinary rectangular column fails first at the corners, where the confinement is weakest. This is followed by bulging of the long sides, which indicates a loss of confinement and a subsequent loss of load-carrying capacity. The composite column, on the other hand, fails by bulging of the short sides near the ends, which suggests that the core circular tube effectively redistributes the internal stresses and delays the onset of local buckling.

Bearing Capacity and Ductility

The quantitative results are the most compelling part of the paper:

Parameter Ordinary Rectangular CFST Composite Rectangular CFST Improvement
Bearing capacity (kN) Reference value 12.5% higher +12.5%
Ductility (displacement ductility factor) Reference value 4.9% higher +4.9%

A 12.5% increase in bearing capacity is a substantial improvement, especially for a structural element where the material cost is a significant portion of the total project cost. The 4.9% increase in ductility is also important, as it means the column can undergo more deformation before failure, which is critical for seismic resistance.

Why the Composite Configuration Works

The core circular tube changes the internal stress distribution in the column. In an ordinary rectangular CFST column, the confinement stress is non-uniform, with the highest confinement at the corners and the lowest at the mid-point of the flat sides. This non-uniformity leads to premature failure at the corners and bulging of the flat sides.

In the composite column, the core circular tube provides a more uniform confinement to the central concrete core. The concrete in the annular space between the two tubes is confined by both the outer rectangular tube and the inner circular tube, which creates a more complex but more effective confinement mechanism. The result is a more uniform stress distribution and a higher overall load-carrying capacity.

Practical Insights and Lessons from the Field

Applications in Building Construction

Composite CFST columns are used in high-rise buildings, bridges, and other structures where high load-carrying capacity and good seismic performance are required. The composite rectangular configuration is particularly useful when the column must have a rectangular cross-section for architectural or structural reasons, but the engineer wants to achieve the performance of a circular column.

I have seen CFST columns used in a number of high-rise projects, and the choice of column shape is often driven by architectural considerations. A rectangular column is easier to integrate with walls and partitions, but a circular column provides better structural performance. The composite rectangular column offers the best of both worlds—the architectural flexibility of a rectangular shape with the structural efficiency of a circular core.

Construction Considerations

From a construction perspective, the composite rectangular column is more complex to fabricate and erect than an ordinary rectangular column. The inner circular tube must be positioned accurately within the outer rectangular tube, and the concrete must be placed in the annular space between the two tubes. This requires careful planning and quality control.

However, the additional construction complexity is justified by the improved performance. In a high-rise building, the cost of the steel tubes is a small fraction of the total construction cost, and the savings from reduced column dimensions can offset the additional fabrication cost.

The Role of Steel Pipe Quality

As a steel pipe manufacturer, I am particularly interested in the quality requirements for the steel tubes used in these columns. The outer rectangular tube is typically made from cold-formed or hot-formed steel, while the inner circular tube is a seamless or welded pipe. The mechanical properties of the steel—yield strength, tensile strength, elongation, and toughness—must meet the design requirements, and the dimensional tolerances must be tight enough to ensure proper fit and concrete placement.

In my experience, the most common issue with CFST columns is not the steel quality but the concrete placement. Voids or honeycombs in the concrete can significantly reduce the load-carrying capacity. The composite configuration with an inner circular tube makes concrete placement more challenging, but it also provides a path for the concrete to flow around the inner tube, which can help to reduce the risk of voids.

Key Questions and Reflections

Is the Composite Configuration Economical?

The 12.5% increase in bearing capacity comes at the cost of an additional inner circular tube. The question is whether the additional steel is justified by the performance improvement. In many cases, the answer is yes, because the increased bearing capacity allows the column dimensions to be reduced, which saves concrete and space.

However, the economic analysis is not straightforward. The inner circular tube adds material and fabrication cost, and the concrete placement is more complex. The engineer must weigh these costs against the benefits of reduced column size and improved performance.

Are There Other Composite Configurations?

The paper focuses on a composite rectangular column with a core circular tube. There are other possible configurations, such as a rectangular outer tube with multiple inner tubes, or a rectangular outer tube with a core that is not circular. Each configuration has its own advantages and disadvantages.

I would be interested in seeing research on other configurations, such as a rectangular outer tube with a core that is an octagonal or elliptical shape. These shapes may provide different confinement characteristics and may be more or less effective depending on the application.

How Does the Aspect Ratio Affect Performance?

The paper uses an aspect ratio of 1.7, which is relatively large. In my experience, the performance of rectangular CFST columns degrades as the aspect ratio increases, because the flat sides become longer and the confinement becomes less effective. The composite configuration may be particularly beneficial for columns with large aspect ratios, where the ordinary rectangular configuration performs poorly.

I would like to see research on the effect of aspect ratio on the performance of composite rectangular CFST columns. This would help engineers determine when the composite configuration is necessary and when an ordinary rectangular column is sufficient.

Study Insights and Implications for Practice

This paper provides valuable experimental data on the axial compression performance of composite rectangular CFST columns. The results show that the composite configuration offers significant improvements in both bearing capacity and ductility compared with ordinary rectangular columns.

For practicing engineers, the key takeaway is that the shape and configuration of the steel tube have a significant influence on the performance of CFST columns. The composite rectangular configuration should be considered when high load-carrying capacity and good ductility are required, especially for columns with large aspect ratios.

For the steel pipe industry, this paper is a reminder that our products are used in a wide variety of structural applications, and the performance of the final structure depends on the interaction between the steel and the concrete. As pipe manufacturers, we should be aware of these applications and ensure that our products meet the requirements of the design codes and standards.

In conclusion, the composite rectangular CFST column is a promising structural element that offers superior performance compared with ordinary rectangular columns. The experimental results from this paper provide a solid foundation for the development of design guidelines and the wider adoption of this configuration in practice.